Your Business Is Bigger Than Etsy (Start Acting Like It)

If Etsy disappeared tomorrow, would your business survive?

Take a second.

Really think about that.

No orders. No search traffic. No payments. Just… gone.

If that idea makes your stomach twist, you’re one of us.

I’ve seen creators giving all the time into a handmade business only to realize, way too late, that Etsy owns the playground. Not them.

But there's a smarter way to grow.

It starts with understanding one hard truth most Etsy sellers ignore:

Etsy is not your business. Etsy is a tool. 

And if it’s the only tool in your toolbox, you're one algorithm change away from panic mode.

Let’s talk about why you must diversify, and how doing it right can actually grow your revenue, protect your time, and give you a business you actually control.

A SPECIAL OFFER FOR YOU FROM OUR SPONSOR

How 15 Small Brands Achieved Remarkable Marketing Results

Stop believing you need a big budget to make an impact. Our latest collection highlights 15 small brands that transformed limited resources into significant market disruption through innovative thinking.

• Case studies revealing ingenious approaches to common marketing challenges

• Practical tactics that delivered 900%+ ROI with minimal investment

• Strategic frameworks for amplifying your brand without amplifying your budget

These actionable insights can be implemented immediately, regardless of your team or budget size. See how small brands are making big waves in today's market.

Get the case studies for free here.

Etsy Gives You Exposure… Until It Doesn’t

You’ve probably heard the success stories:

But what you don’t hear?

“I relied only on Etsy, and my traffic vanished overnight.”

“I got suspended without warning.”

“I was ranking on page 1 — then I wasn’t.”

And just like that, the dream turns into a customer service nightmare.

This isn’t scaring you. This is reality.

Etsy changes its algorithm constantly.

It enforces its rules inconsistently. And you are one email away from being locked out of the shop you built.

Would you build a house on land someone else can take back any day?

No?

Then don’t build your business that way either.

What No One Tells You About Selling on Etsy

You don’t own your audience. You don’t control your brand experience. You’re paying Etsy 10-20% in fees on every order.

You can’t collect emails, upsell easily, or set your own return policies. Every sale builds Etsy’s empire, not yours.

The Etsy algorithm doesn’t care that you hand-painted 80 mugs last weekend.

It doesn’t care that your listings took 4 hours to perfect.

It ranks based on what sells fast, what Etsy wants to push, and what makes them money.

That’s the game.

And unless you start playing a bigger one, you’ll always be at the mercy of someone else’s system.

A SPECIAL OFFER FOR YOU FROM OUR SPONSOR

Start learning AI in 2025

Everyone talks about AI, but no one has the time to learn it. So, we found the easiest way to learn AI in as little time as possible: The Rundown AI.

It's a free AI newsletter that keeps you up-to-date on the latest AI news, and teaches you how to apply it in just 5 minutes a day.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses – tailored to your needs.

Sign up to start learning.

So What Do You Do?

You start building something, Etsy can’t take away from you.

That means two things:

1. You create additional revenue streams.

2. You create places you fully own and control.

Let’s unpack both.

1. Diversify Your Platforms (Before You’re Forced To)

If you’re only selling on Etsy right now, the scariest time to diversify is after something goes wrong.

But imagine this instead:

You open a Shopify store where you control the branding and customer experience. You start selling on Faire or Abound to get into wholesale. You license one of your best designs and get paid on repeat. You launch digital downloads or courses based on your craft. You run a newsletter and own your customer list.

Suddenly, you’re not relying on Etsy. Etsy becomes just one channel in your ecosystem, not your lifeline.

You wouldn’t invest your entire savings into one stock. Don’t do it with your income either.

2. Own Your Audience (So You Can Sell on Your Terms)

Let me ask you something:

If Etsy banned you tomorrow, how would you tell your best customers?

If the answer is “I couldn’t,” then we’ve found the biggest hole in your business.

When you don’t collect emails or build a direct connection with your buyers, you’re not building a business, you’re just borrowing one.

This is why you need an email list. A simple landing page and an automated freebie can be the start of your next launch, your next course, or your next best-selling product.

Every Etsy customer should be invited to your email list. Offer them something of value, a coupon, a behind-the-scenes PDF, or a tutorial. Make it worth it.

Because once you own the relationship, you’re no longer a vendor. You’re a brand.

Etsy Can Still Be Part of Your Strategy

This isn’t about burning down your Etsy store. It’s about making it less risky.

You can still use Etsy. It’s a great discovery engine. A great way to test product ideas. A great starting point.

But don’t end there.

Use Etsy to drive people to your newsletter. Use Etsy profits to fund your Shopify store. Use Etsy’s traffic to test what sells, then build your best-sellers into a real business that exists outside of their sandbox.

If you’re making money on Etsy, good. Now protect it.

So What’s Your Next Step?

Here’s a challenge: This week, do one thing to reduce your Etsy dependence.

• Buy a domain name

• Set up a free ConvertKit landing page

• Create a freebie to collect emails

• Research Shopify or Square

• Pitch your first wholesale client

• Or simply email 10 past customers and invite them to your list

Start small. But start.

Your future self will thank you when the Etsy algorithm changes and you’re calm instead of crushed.

Because this time? You’ll be ready.

You won’t just have a shop.

You’ll have a business.

Have a nice day,

Miroslav from The Design Nexus

TOOLS YOU SHOULD TRY

Even if you sell products other than mugs or t-shirts, it doesn't mean it will cost you more.

There are tools that can help you with the tasks, and most of them have free versions.

• Research: Alura

• Graphic Designs: Creative Fabrica

• Design Editing: Canva, Kittl

• Vectorizing: Vectorizer AI

• POD Fulfillment: Printful, Printify

Disclaimer: Within the article, you will find affiliate links. If you decide to purchase through these links, I want to sincerely assure you that I will receive a commission at no extra cost to you.