What Bad Reviews Say About Your Shop

When I opened my first Etsy shop, I was excited and a little nervous at the same time.

I had my experience with print-on-demand on Redbubble, but Etsy was something different.

So, I worked hard on my products, carefully designing each one.

In my head, I imagined happy customers, glowing reviews, and daily sales.

But then, it happened - a bad review.

My stomach sank as I read the words.

I felt embarrassed, frustrated, and even a little angry.

Let’s talk about bad reviews and what they really mean for your shop.

A SPECIAL OFFER FOR YOU FROM OUR SPONSOR

Product Ideas to Sell on Etsy

Make $200 to $500k by selling digital products without quitting your 9 to 5 job. It's easy to sell online if you have product ideas.

Here is a list of profitable digital product ideas for Etsy that can be created with AI to make money.

Get The Ideas

THE PSYCHOLOGY
What Makes Bad Reviews So Hard?

When someone writes a bad review, it is personal.

As a creator, you put your time into your work, and someone criticizes it.

You think, What if no one wants to buy from me now? 

That’s a nightmare.

But there is no shop, that has only good reviews.

Every seller, big or small, gets some negative feedback. The important thing is how you respond to it.

THE PROBLEM
Why Do Bad Reviews Matter?

Bad reviews can affect your business in a few ways:

• They can scare off new customers. When people read reviews, they want to know what to expect. A bad review might make them wonder if your product is worth it.

• They might hurt your confidence. Negative feedback can make you doubt yourself. That’s normal, but it’s not helpful.

• They might affect your shop's ranking. If you sell online, platforms like Etsy or Amazon might lower your shop’s visibility if your reviews drop too much.

However, keep this in your mind - one or two bad reviews won’t ruin your shop. 

What matters is the bigger picture.

A SPECIAL OFFER FOR YOU FROM OUR SPONSOR

Run CTV Ads on Roku This Q5

Peak shopping season isn’t over yet! Two thirds of consumers plan to shop the week after Christmas, and “Q5” – the period between Christmas and mid-January – has become a significant shopping window.* Roku Ads Manager makes it easy to run self-serve CTV ads and reach shoppers where they’re streaming post-holidays. Get started for as little as $500 and find your next customers on the big screen. (*National Retail Federation, 2023)

Discover CTV performance on Roku

CUSTOMERS THINKING
Why Do People Leave Bad Reviews?

Understanding why someone writes a bad review can help you handle it.

Here are some common reasons:

• The product didn’t meet their expectations. Maybe they thought it would look or work differently.

• Shipping took too long. Even if delays are out of your control, customers might blame you.

• They’re having a bad day. Sometimes, people take out their frustrations on others. Your shop might just be an easy target.

• Competitors might play dirty. Unfortunately, some sellers try to hurt others by leaving fake bad reviews. It’s unfair, but it happens.

Knowing the reason behind a bad review can help you decide what to do next.

THE WRONG WAYS
Common Ways Sellers Handle Bad Reviews (And Why They Don’t Always Work)

You might feel like deleting the review or arguing with the customer, but these approaches often backfire:

• Ignoring the review. While it’s tempting to pretend it doesn’t exist, other customers will see it. They might wonder why you didn’t respond.

• Blaming the customer. If you argue or point fingers, it can make things worse. People respect businesses that handle problems calmly and kindly.

• Offering refunds without question. This might solve the issue, but it can also encourage dishonest buyers to take advantage of you.

These methods don’t always help because they don’t address the bigger picture: how your shop handles challenges.

THE SOLUTION
A Better Way

I learned a few things about bad reviews over time.

Take a deep breath. Read the review carefully, but don’t reply right away. Give yourself time to process it.

Check if it’s fair. Did you make a mistake? If so, admit it and fix it. If not, remember that you can’t please everyone.

Reply politely. Thank the customer for their feedback. Explain how you’ll address their concern or why their experience isn’t typical for your shop.

For example:

• “I’m sorry to hear you’re unhappy. I’ll message you to see how we can fix this.”

• “Thank you for letting us know. We always try to do better, and your feedback helps.”

Learn from it. Bad reviews can teach you something. Maybe you need clearer product photos or better packaging. Use feedback to improve.

Keep going. One bad review doesn’t define your shop. Focus on your happy customers and keep doing your best.

OTHER TIPS
Bad Reviews Aren’t Always a Bad Thing

Believe it or not, bad reviews can actually help your business.

• They make your shop look real. A mix of good and bad reviews shows customers that your feedback is honest. If every review is perfect, people might think they’re fake.

• They give you a chance to show great customer service. When you handle a bad review well, it shows other customers that you care.

• They help you stand out. Some shoppers trust a business more when they see how it deals with problems.

Tips to Protect Your Shop

You can’t stop bad reviews completely, but you can reduce them by being proactive:

• Be clear about what you’re selling. Use good photos and detailed descriptions so customers know what to expect.

• Communicate. Let customers know if there’s a delay or issue. They’ll appreciate the honesty.

• Deliver quality. Make sure your products match their descriptions and are well-made.

• Ask for feedback. Happy customers often don’t leave reviews unless you remind them. A quick thank-you message can go a long way.

Getting a bad review is awful, but it’s not the end of the world.

Remember, every business faces this challenge. What matters is how you handle it.

Stay calm, learn from it, and keep moving forward.

Your shop has more than one review.

It’s the work you’ve put in, the happy customers you’ve served, and the future you’re building.

Miroslav from The Design Nexus

TOOLS YOU SHOULD TRY

Even if you sell products other than mugs or t-shirts, it doesn't mean it will cost you more.

There are tools that can help you with the tasks, and most of them have free versions.

• Research: Alura

• Graphic Designs: Creative Fabrica

• Design Editing: Canva, Kittl

• Vectorizing: Vectorizer AI

• POD Fulfillment: Printful, Printify

Disclaimer: Within the article, you will find affiliate links. If you decide to purchase through these links, I want to sincerely assure you that I will receive a commission at no extra cost to you.