How to Build a Recognizable Brand on Etsy

and why Etsy isn’t enough.

Author

Miroslav Novohradsky
June 15, 2025

In partnership with

Back when I opened my Etsy shop, I was just excited to sell something. Anything.

My first listing? A cat t-shirt design I priced at $16.99.

I didn’t think about branding. I didn’t have a logo. I didn’t even have a color palette. My store name? Let’s not talk about it.

But something happened about six months in that forced me to wake up.

A customer left me a glowing five-star review. But then she messaged me with this: “I’m trying to find your shop again for a gift, but I forgot your name. Are you the one who made the pouch with the leaf print?”

That’s when I realized something painful.

People liked my products.

But they didn’t remember me.

Let me show you what I did next, and what I’d do differently if I had to start over.

Because if you want your Etsy shop to survive and grow, you don’t just need good products. You need a recognizable brand. One people search for, remember, and come back to.

I’ll walk you through exactly how to build that brand and why your Etsy shop isn’t enough to carry your business long-term.

But first...

A SPECIAL OFFER FOR YOU FROM OUR SPONSOR

Stay In The Business Know with 1440

Are you looking for easy breakdowns and knowledge deep dives on the latest key concepts to help you understand business and finance topics? Finance news doesn’t have to be confusing. 1440’s weekly newsletter explains markets, policy, and investing in plain English—complete with charts, context, and links to learn more.

What Even Is a Brand on Etsy?

A brand isn’t just a logo or a cute shop banner. It’s not your name, or even your niche.

Your brand is the emotion someone feels when they land on your page.

Are they inspired? Cozy? Excited? Trusting?

If you’re not shaping that emotional response deliberately, you’re leaving money—and growth on the table.

So, how do you build that emotional signature?

Let’s get practical.

Step 1: Start With Your Story

People don’t connect with products.

They connect with people.

What’s your why? Why did you start this shop? What are you hoping to create beyond the sales?

You don’t need a dramatic backstory. You just need a real one.

Did you start crocheting during maternity leave? Were you bored in your office job? Did your grandmother teach you how to wood-burn signs?

Tell that story in your About section. Show your face. Speak in your voice. Use words your best friend would recognize as you.

When customers know you, they trust you.

And trust builds brand memory.

Step 2: Use Visual Consistency

This is where most Etsy sellers start: logos, color palettes, and photo styles. All important, but only if they feel personal.

Don’t copy some fancy brand board from Pinterest. Instead, ask: what three words do I want customers to feel when they see my shop?

Warm. Playful. Natural.

Or maybe: Sleek. Modern. Clever.

Once you have those words, build your visuals around them. Use the same background in your product shots. Pick two fonts and stick with them. Make your packaging reflect your vibe.

The goal is simple: make your shop look like it came from one person, not ten.

Step 3: Speak With One Voice

Your product descriptions, your messages, even your thank-you notes—should all sound like the same person wrote them.

Don’t be formal if you’re quirky. Don’t be bubbly if you’re calm and thoughtful.

Your tone is part of your brand. It’s how you build relationships, not just transactions.

Quick tip: read your listings out loud. Do they sound like something you’d say in a conversation?

If not, rewrite them until they do.

Now here’s where it gets serious.

Etsy Isn’t a Branding Platform (And That’s a Problem)

Etsy is a wonderful place to start a brand.

It’s not a great place to own one.

You don’t own your customer list. You can’t follow up via email. You can’t build a real content funnel. Etsy can change the algorithm, tweak the search, suspend your account… any time, for any reason.

If all your brand-building happens inside Etsy, you’re walking on eggshells.

So what should you do instead?

Let’s open this up.

Build Your Brand Outside Etsy Too

Think of Etsy as your storefront.

But your brand? That’s your entire neighborhood.

Here’s how to expand:

  • Start an Email List: Offer a freebie, a coupon, a download, a printable guide, in exchange for email signups. Use something like ConvertKit or Flodesk. Once a week, send tips, behind-the-scenes, or new launches. Keep it light and personal. Like you’re writing to a friend.

  • Create a Simple Website: It doesn’t need to be fancy. Just a place where your story, your products, and your brand vibe live all in one space you control.

  • Use Social Media Thoughtfully: Pick one platform. Not five. Use it to build relationships, not just push products. Share your process. Ask questions. Show your workspace. Let people connect with the human behind the shop.

  • Collaborate With Other Creators: Host a giveaway. Share each other’s posts. Write guest blog articles. This builds trust by association… a key ingredient in any strong brand.

You don’t need to do all of these at once. But you do need to start somewhere.

The most successful Etsy sellers I know (all of them) have a presence beyond the platform.

They show up where their customers are. They tell a story. They build a vibe that people come back for.

Etsy brings people to you.

Your brand makes them stay.

A SPECIAL OFFER FOR YOU FROM OUR SPONSOR

Learn AI in 5 minutes a day

This is the easiest way for a busy person wanting to learn AI in as little time as possible:

  1. Sign up for The Rundown AI newsletter

  2. They send you 5-minute email updates on the latest AI news and how to use it

  3. You learn how to become 2x more productive by leveraging AI

Remember that customer I told you about at the beginning? The one who couldn’t remember my shop name?

She found me again.

You know how?

She said, “I finally recognized your product photo style. It had that soft, dreamy light and the eucalyptus sprigs again.”

That moment changed everything.

Not because I got the sale.

But because I saw (visually, emotionally, viscerally) that my brand had taken root.

And that’s the goal.

Not just more sales.

Recognition. Trust. Connection.

Have a wonderful and productive day,

Miroslav from The Design Nexus

TOOLS YOU SHOULD TRY

Even if you sell products other than mugs or t-shirts, it doesn't mean it will cost you more.

There are tools that can help you with the tasks, and most of them have free versions.

Disclaimer: Within the article, you will find affiliate links. If you decide to purchase through these links, I want to sincerely assure you that I will receive a commission at no extra cost to you.

Reply

or to participate.